Third US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East
The USS Theodore Roosevelt arrived in the US Central Command area on November 15-16, bringing three US carriers to the region, after Iran claimed drone attacks on Bahrain.
Who covered it: 12 US outlets, 12 international, 4 state media.
Updated · Since 2026-11-15 · 38 articles and posts from 28 sources.

What happened
- Iran fired drones at a US radar installation at Sheikh Isa Air Base in Bahrain, its third attack on American targets there in five days. Bahrain said it intercepted the drones, and a US official said a US fighter jet later struck an Iranian missile launch site on Qeshm Island. Minnesota Star Tribune, The Straits Times
- The Israeli Institute for National Security Studies said the current US naval presence in the Middle East exceeds the force deployed at the peak of the war in February and March. It said US air power at land bases remains below March levels. The Express Tribune
- CNBC reported that new US intelligence indicated Iran was developing plans that could target senior Trump administration officials with a so-called dirty bomb. The report said this was an effort to develop options rather than evidence of an imminent attack, and a White House spokesperson said there were 'no credible threats to the homeland'. CNBC
- US Central Command said on X that the USS Theodore Roosevelt 'is currently operating in the CENTCOM area of responsibility as part of a scheduled deployment'. Sources report this brings the US to three carrier strike groups in the region, alongside the USS George H.W. Bush and USS George Washington. NDTV, The Hill
- Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps said six tankers had been hit by mines or projectiles in the Strait of Hormuz since Sunday. The UK Maritime Trade Operations confirmed one tanker was struck by an unknown projectile and caught fire, with no casualties; The National noted the Guard's claims could not be independently verified. The Independent, The National (UAE) (state media)
- Iran fired six drones at a US radar system at Bahrain's Al-Rifaa helicopter base, saying it had a 'precise and successful impact'. Bahrain's military said it intercepted all the drones, and the sources say there was little or no damage. The National (UAE) (state media), Anadolu Agency (state media)
- Iranian Deputy Foreign Minister Kazem Gharibabadi said Iran will not give the IAEA access to its damaged nuclear facilities 'until Iran’s conditions are met and the war has permanently ended'. Fox News
Follow this story
Get an email when the story changes: a new way of telling it, a new week in how it’s framed, or a statement from the US government. At most one a day in the first week, then once a week, on Fridays. After two weeks with no change, we stop.
Confirming also makes your free Semblen account, with a 7-day Pro trial. No card.
Every email has a one-click unfollow link.
What the sources show
The claims the tellings below repeat, each as its sources put it, checked against other sources the way Semblen checks an article’s claims.
The USS Theodore Roosevelt entered the US Central Command area of responsibility on Sunday, Nov 15, 2026.
Repeated by: The Jerusalem Post, Hindustan Times, The National (UAE) (state media)
Partly supportedPartly supported: The evidence confirms the USS Theodore Roosevelt arrived in the Middle East/CENTCOM AOR around Nov 16, 2026 (per CENTCOM's own announcement that day), but does not confirm the specific entry date of Nov 15.
- The sources add: U.S. Central Command said on Monday that a third American aircraft carrier had arrived in the Middle East, without the source naming the carrier. apnews.com ↗
- The sources add: The USS Theodore Roosevelt was pictured leaving Yokosuka, near Tokyo, on Oct. 19, 2026, to take part in the Keen Sword 27 exercise. apnews.com ↗
- Not in the sources we found: The USS Theodore Roosevelt entered the US Central Command area of responsibility.
We read 6 sources; 2 addressed this claim.
As its sources put it (3)
- “The USS Theodore Roosevelt entered the US Central Command (CENTCOM) area of responsibility on Sunday” — The Jerusalem Post
- “The USS Theodore Roosevelt aircraft carrier arrived in the Middle East on Sunday” — Hindustan Times
- “The USS Theodore Roosevelt aircraft carrier arrived in the Middle East on Sunday, a US official told The National.” — The National (UAE) (state media)
🔒 The US now has three aircraft carrier strike groups in the Middle East, the second time in 2026 and the first since April.
Repeated by: The Hill, Bloomberg, New York Post
Partly supported🔒 CENTCOM said on X that the USS Theodore Roosevelt is operating in its area of responsibility as part of a scheduled deployment.
Repeated by: NDTV, Fox News
Reported elsewhere🔒 The US military says it shot down two Iranian drones headed for Bahrain on Friday, Nov 13, 2026, with no casualties or damage.
Repeated by: NDTV, The National (UAE) (state media)
Partly supported🔒 Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps says six tankers were hit by mines or projectiles in the Strait of Hormuz since Sunday, Nov 15, 2026.
Repeated by: The Independent, New York Post
The sources addThe sources behind each of these checks are part of Semblen Pro. Start a free trial. 7 days free. No card.
A verdict is the claim check’s, with the sources it rests on, never a rating of the outlets that repeat the claim.
How the story is being told
5 ways of telling it run through the coverage. Most sources mix more than one; each is listed under the tellings its own words support.
A military buildup that keeps Trump's options open
None of the 4 state media outlets we read told it this way.
Repeats: The USS Theodore Roosevelt entered the US Central Command area of responsibility on Sunday, Nov 15, 2026. Partly supported; The US now has three aircraft carrier strike groups in the Middle East, the second time in 2026 and the first since April. Partly supported; CENTCOM said on X that the USS Theodore Roosevelt is operating in its area of responsibility as part of a scheduled deployment. Reported elsewhere
These sources describe the third carrier's arrival as adding firepower and options while Trump weighs whether to resume strikes. They stress fleet numbers, the blockade, the strain on the Navy and the comparison with earlier buildups in April and 2003.
“gives President Donald Trump more military options if he chooses to restart active hostilities with Iran”Bloomberg
“Keeping three carriers in the region risks exacerbating the Navy’s current readiness woes”The Straits Times
“making a dramatic show of military might as President Donald Trump keeps his options open for next steps in the Iran war”KSTP
- Leads with
- The size and options of the US naval force
Each source’s words (5)
- “gives President Donald Trump more military options if he chooses to restart active hostilities with Iran” — Bloomberg
- “making a dramatic show of military might as President Donald Trump keeps his options open for next steps in the Iran war” — KSTP
- “bringing more U.S. service members and firepower, as President Trump weighs his options against Iran” — The Hill
- “The Iran War has put tremendous strain on the Navy, with deployments now being extended.” — The Daily Caller
- “Keeping three carriers in the region risks exacerbating the Navy’s current readiness woes” — The Straits Times
🔒 A renewed Iranian escalation against US forces, Bahrain and shipping
Repeats: The US now has three aircraft carrier strike groups in the Middle East, the second time in 2026 and the first since April. Partly supported; The US military says it shot down two Iranian drones headed for Bahrain on Friday, Nov 13, 2026, with no casualties or damage. Partly supported; Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps says six tankers were hit by mines or projectiles in the Strait of Hormuz since Sunday, Nov 15, 2026. The sources add
🔒 A stalled peace track and a war with no exit
🔒 A war weighed down by American political fallout
None of the 4 state media outlets we read told it this way.
🔒 Ships, dates and basic facts reported tersely
None of the 12 US outlets we read told it this way.
Repeats: The USS Theodore Roosevelt entered the US Central Command area of responsibility on Sunday, Nov 15, 2026. Partly supported; The US now has three aircraft carrier strike groups in the Middle East, the second time in 2026 and the first since April. Partly supported; CENTCOM said on X that the USS Theodore Roosevelt is operating in its area of responsibility as part of a scheduled deployment. Reported elsewhere
How each of these is told, in its sources’ own words, is part of Semblen Pro. Start a free trial. 7 days free. No card.
“Says less about” is shown only where we checked every source listed and found the topic absent. Which kinds of source told the story each way counts only the sources we read, grouped by kind, never by lean.
Where the coverage agrees
Part of Semblen Pro. Start a free trial. 7 days free. No card.
What each outlet chose to put first and leave out. Whether what it says is true is a separate question. For the claims the tellings repeat, see what the sources show.
How the framing changed, week by week
3 periods, each with what changed and the quotes that show it: part of Semblen Pro. Start a free trial. 7 days free. No card.
What the photos show
The lead photo of each article, as its publisher chose it. The description is ours, written by AI from the photo; the caption and credit are the publisher’s.
1 of 33
-
Anadolu Agency (state media) · USS Theodore Roosevelt to join 2 US aircraft carriers in Middle East within next day: Report original ↗
Shows: A large gray aircraft carrier is moored at a pier.
-
Hindustan Times · Third US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East amid Iran tensions: Report original ↗
Shows: A large gray aircraft carrier with many parked jets on its flight deck sits in calm water.
Caption: “The USS Theodore Roosevelt aircraft carrier arrived in the Middle East on Sunday. (AP)”
-
The Jerusalem Post · Third US aircraft carrier enters Middle East as Trump heads to China for talks with Xi, Putin original ↗
Shows: A large aircraft carrier moves across blue ocean.
Caption: “The USS Theodore Roosevelt from the bay doors of a V-22 Osprey after taking off during a Rim of the Pacific (RIMPAC) military exercise in waters south of the Hawaiian Islands, U.S., July 13, 2026.” Photo: Nimitz-class aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt (CVN 71) returns to Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam to participate in the final events of Exercise Rim of the Pacific 2026, July 28, 2026. (credit: US Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist Seaman Mark Bergado)
-
The National (UAE) (state media) · USS Theodore Roosevelt aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East original ↗
Shows: An aircraft carrier with many parked jets on its deck sails across open blue water.
Caption: “The aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt earlier this month. Photo: US Navy”
-
The National (UAE) (state media) · Middle East latest: USS Theodore Roosevelt aircraft carrier arrives in region original ↗
Shows: Several cargo ships and boats sit on a calm, hazy sea.
-
The National (UAE) (state media) · Iran escalates threats against US forces and Gulf states as third American carrier arrives original ↗
Shows: An aircraft carrier cruises across dark blue ocean, leaving white wake.
Caption: “USS Theodore Roosevelt entered the US Central Command area of responsibility on Sunday. Reuters”
-
Al Jazeera (state-funded) · USS Roosevelt arrives in Middle East: Is the US-Iran war about to resume? original ↗
Shows: Fighter jets sit on a carrier flight deck in front of a gray ship's island.
Caption: “US Navy aircraft sit on the flight deck on board the aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt [File: Michelle Bir/AFP]”
-
Anadolu Agency (state media) · US increases carrier presence in Middle East to 3 as USS Theodore Roosevelt arrives in region: Report original ↗
Shows: A twin-propeller gray aircraft with number 22 on its nose lands on a carrier flight deck over blue ocean.
-
NDTV · US Sends 3rd Aircraft Carrier To Middle East Day After Iran Attacks Bahrain original ↗
-
The Independent · Iran warns sixth oil tanker in Strait of Hormuz struck in 24 hours as regional tensions escalate original ↗
Shows: Several cargo ships sit on calm, hazy sea; the largest on the left has a red crane.
-
KSTP · Third American aircraft carrier arrives in the Middle East as Trump keeps options open in Iran war original ↗
Shows: An older man in a dark overcoat and red tie speaks outdoors while a hand holds a microphone toward him.
Caption: “President Donald Trump speaks with reporters before departing on Marine One from the South Lawn of the White House, Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)”
-
The Hindu · Third American aircraft carrier arrives in West Asia as Trump keeps options open in Iran war original ↗
Shows: A large gray aircraft carrier with jets on its deck sits in blue water, flanked by two small tugboats.
Caption: “The U.S. aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt. File. | Photo Credit: AP”
-
Fox News · Third US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East as Iran rules out UN nuclear inspections original ↗
Shows: A gray fighter jet with the tail number 505 launches from a carrier flight deck.
Caption: “An EA-18G Growler assigned to Electric Attack Squadron (VAQ) 137 lands aboard the aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt (CVN-71) while the ship is moored in Honolulu, Hawaii, during Exercise RIMPAC (Rim of the Pacific) 2026 on July 17, 2026. (Michelle Bir / AFP via Getty Images)”
-
Bloomberg · Third Aircraft Carrier Arrives in Persian Gulf, Boosting Options original ↗
Shows: A large aircraft carrier with jets on its deck sails across blue ocean.
Caption: “The USS Theodore Roosevelt Oct. 21 in the Philippine Sea.” Photo: grapher: Petty Officer 2nd Class Aaron Ha/US Navy
-
NDTV · 3 US Aircraft Carriers Operating In Middle East original ↗
-
The Straits Times · Third US aircraft carrier arrives in Persian Gulf, boosting options original ↗
Shows: A large aircraft carrier with many parked aircraft sails across open blue sea.
Caption: “The Nimitz-class aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt and its strike group were reportedly heading to the Middle East, joining two other strike groups already deployed in the region. PHOTO: AFP”
-
The Independent · Third US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East as Trump keeps Iran war options open original ↗
Shows: A large grey aircraft carrier moves across blue water toward a coastline dense with houses, a marina full of sailboats.
Caption: “The aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt (CVN 71) leaves its San Diego homeport ( U.S. Navy via Getty Images )”
-
Breitbart · Third U.S. Aircraft Carrier Arrives in Middle East, Joining 50,000 Troops in Iran Standoff original ↗
Shows: Jet fighters parked on a carrier flight deck with a helicopter hovering above; crew in green jerseys stand nearby.
Caption: “U.S. Sailors conduct flight operations with an MH-60S Sea Hawk assigned to Helicopter Sea Combat Squadron (HSC) 8 on the flight deck of Nimitz-class aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt (CVN 71), Nov. 16, 2026. Theodore Roosevelt is deployed to the U.S. 5th Fleet area of operations to support maritime security and stability in the Middle East. (U.S. Navy photo)” Photo: U.S. Navy / DVIDS
-
The Hill · 3rd aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East as Trump weighs Iran options original ↗
Shows: Fighter jets are parked on an aircraft carrier's flight deck at sea.
-
The Independent · Vance claims Iran won’t be a ‘forever war’ even as Trump sends third aircraft carrier to Middle East original ↗
-
New York Post · USS Roosevelt arrives in Middle East as Trump mulls new Iran strikes original ↗
Shows: A large aircraft carrier with many parked aircraft crosses open blue sea.
-
Dawn · USS Theodore Roosevelt joins US warships in Middle East original ↗
Shows: A large black serif capital letter D is centered on a plain white background.
-
CGTN (state media) · 3rd US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East amid Iran tensions original ↗
Shows: A large gray ship superstructure rises behind a propeller aircraft on a flight deck.
-
The Times of India · Vance says US will not fight 'forever war' with Iran, defends Trump's military action original ↗
Shows: Two men in dark suits and red ties salute with their right hands in front of a large American flag.
-
The Straits Times · Iran targets Bahrain as Middle East temperatures rise again original ↗
Shows: A man in a white long shirt and trousers walks past a wall with black metal fence above.
Caption: “A man walks in front of a wall where graffiti has been blackened out in a Shi’ite village in Bahrain, on Nov 6. PHOTO: REUTERS”
-
Anadolu Agency (state media) · EXPLAINER - Why US now has 3 aircraft carriers in Middle East original ↗
Shows: A large gray aircraft carrier is moored at a pier.
-
Breitbart · Iran Steps up Threats as Third American Carrier Arrives in Middle East original ↗
Shows: A large aircraft carrier moves across calm blue ocean.
Caption: “190715-N-IW125-1047 PACIFIC OCEAN (July 15, 2019) The aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt (CVN 71) transits the Pacific Ocean. Theodore Roosevelt is conducting routine operations in the Eastern Pacific Ocean. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist Seaman Nicholas V. Huynh)” Photo: (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist Seaman Nicholas V. Huynh
-
CNBC · Third U.S. carrier arrives as fears of renewed Iran conflict grow original ↗
Shows: A dark blue cargo ship labeled 'LUNA II' and 'PANAMA' emits a plume of smoke on hazy water.
-
The Daily Caller · US Deploys Third Aircraft Carrier As Iran War Stretches Navy To Its Limits original ↗
Shows: Rows of sailors in dark dress uniforms and white caps line the edge of a large gray warship's deck.
-
Democracy Now! · Iran Attacks U.S. Radar Station in Bahrain, Says It Captured U.S. Drone original ↗
Shows: Three men in camouflage uniforms and green berets stand around a tripod-mounted machine gun on a raised platform.
-
The Express Tribune · US naval presence in Middle East exceeds peak of Iran war: Israeli institute original ↗
Shows: A large container ship with stacked containers sails on open water.
Caption: “A view of Iranian-flagged cargo ship M/V Touska as the US Navy Arleigh Burke-class Aegis guided missile destroyer USS Spruance conducts its interception in a location given as the north Arabian Seaon April 19, 2026. Photo: Reuters”
-
NBC News · A 2-month lull ends with Iran’s third strike on U.S. targets in Bahrain original ↗
Shows: A large dark smoke plume rises above a city skyline across a bay.
Caption: “An Iranian missile strike on the U.S. Navy's 5th Fleet in Manama, Bahrain in February. Anadolu via Getty Images”
-
The Irish Times · Iran attacks US military radar system in Bahrain with drones original ↗
Shows: A gray-haired, bearded man speaks into a cluster of microphones, including one labeled PRESS TV.
Caption: “Iran's foreign minister Abbas Araghchi speaks to media representatives in Islamabad, Pakistan, on Monday. He was visiting Oman on Tuesday. Photograph: AFP/Getty”
The week’s stories, by email
Every Friday, the stories we follow that changed that week: what happened, who covered it, and every way each one is being told. Just your email address, no account.
We’ll email you a link to confirm. Every email has a one-click unsubscribe link.
All the coverage, by day
Every article and post we read (38)
2026-11-15
Anadolu Agency (state media) · USS Theodore Roosevelt to join 2 US aircraft carriers in Middle East within next day: Report original ↗
Hindustan Times · Third US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East amid Iran tensions: Report original ↗
The Times of Israel · Third US aircraft carrier said to arrive in Mideast as Washington shores up troops original ↗
2026-11-16
The Jerusalem Post · Third US aircraft carrier enters Middle East as Trump heads to China for talks with Xi, Putin original ↗
The National (UAE) (state media) · USS Theodore Roosevelt aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East original ↗
The National (UAE) (state media) · Middle East latest: USS Theodore Roosevelt aircraft carrier arrives in region original ↗
The National (UAE) (state media) · Iran escalates threats against US forces and Gulf states as third American carrier arrives original ↗
Al Jazeera (state-funded) · USS Roosevelt arrives in Middle East: Is the US-Iran war about to resume? original ↗
Anadolu Agency (state media) · US increases carrier presence in Middle East to 3 as USS Theodore Roosevelt arrives in region: Report original ↗
NDTV · US Sends 3rd Aircraft Carrier To Middle East Day After Iran Attacks Bahrain original ↗
The Independent · Iran warns sixth oil tanker in Strait of Hormuz struck in 24 hours as regional tensions escalate original ↗
KSTP · Third American aircraft carrier arrives in the Middle East as Trump keeps options open in Iran war original ↗
KSTP · Third US aircraft carrier arrives in the Middle East as Trump keeps options open in the Iran war · ran KSTP’s copy, counted once
WRAL · Third American aircraft carrier arrives in the Middle East as Trump keeps options open in Iran war · ran KSTP’s copy, counted once
The Hindu · Third American aircraft carrier arrives in West Asia as Trump keeps options open in Iran war original ↗
Fox News · Third US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East as Iran rules out UN nuclear inspections original ↗
Bloomberg · Third Aircraft Carrier Arrives in Persian Gulf, Boosting Options original ↗
Anchorage Daily News · A third aircraft carrier arrives in the Middle East as Trump keeps options open in the Iran war · ran KSTP’s copy, counted once
NDTV · 3 US Aircraft Carriers Operating In Middle East original ↗
The Straits Times · Third US aircraft carrier arrives in Persian Gulf, boosting options original ↗
The Guardian · Third US aircraft carrier brings thousands more troops to Middle East original ↗ · ran KSTP’s copy, counted once
The Independent · Third US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East as Trump keeps Iran war options open original ↗
Breitbart · Third U.S. Aircraft Carrier Arrives in Middle East, Joining 50,000 Troops in Iran Standoff original ↗
The Hill · 3rd aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East as Trump weighs Iran options original ↗
The Independent · Vance claims Iran won’t be a ‘forever war’ even as Trump sends third aircraft carrier to Middle East original ↗
PBS NewsHour · Third U.S. aircraft carrier in Middle East as Trump keeps options open in Iran war · ran KSTP’s copy, counted once
New York Post · USS Roosevelt arrives in Middle East as Trump mulls new Iran strikes original ↗
Washington Examiner · USS Theodore Roosevelt aircraft carrier arrives in the Middle East original ↗
Dawn · USS Theodore Roosevelt joins US warships in Middle East original ↗
2026-11-17
CGTN (state media) · 3rd US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East amid Iran tensions original ↗
Hindustan Times · Vance says Trump will end Iran war before 2028, rules out ‘forever war’ as third US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East original ↗
Malay Mail · Three US aircraft carriers now near Iran: Is Washington preparing for escalation? · ran NDTV’s copy, counted once
The Times of India · Vance says US will not fight 'forever war' with Iran, defends Trump's military action original ↗
The Straits Times · Iran targets Bahrain as Middle East temperatures rise again original ↗
Anadolu Agency (state media) · EXPLAINER - Why US now has 3 aircraft carriers in Middle East original ↗
Al Arabiya (state media) · Is Iran using blackmail approach on US? original ↗
Breitbart · Iran Steps up Threats as Third American Carrier Arrives in Middle East original ↗
CNBC · Third U.S. carrier arrives as fears of renewed Iran conflict grow original ↗
The Daily Caller · US Deploys Third Aircraft Carrier As Iran War Stretches Navy To Its Limits original ↗
Democracy Now! · Iran Attacks U.S. Radar Station in Bahrain, Says It Captured U.S. Drone original ↗
The Express Tribune · US naval presence in Middle East exceeds peak of Iran war: Israeli institute original ↗
NBC News · A 2-month lull ends with Iran’s third strike on U.S. targets in Bahrain original ↗
The Irish Times · Iran attacks US military radar system in Bahrain with drones original ↗
Minnesota Star Tribune · A 2-month lull ends with Iran's third strike on US targets in Bahrain original ↗
How we found the coverage
From our feeds: Anadolu Agency (state media), Hindustan Times, The Times of Israel, The Jerusalem Post, The National (UAE) (state media), Al Jazeera (state-funded), NDTV, The Independent, KSTP, The Hindu, Fox News, Bloomberg, The Straits Times, Breitbart, The Hill, CGTN (state media), The Times of India, Al Arabiya (state media), The Daily Caller.
From a news search: New York Post, Washington Examiner, Dawn, CNBC, Democracy Now!, The Express Tribune, NBC News, The Irish Times, Minnesota Star Tribune.
Each item was kept only after a check that it is about this story. Wire copies that other outlets ran word for word are named and counted once. Sources are grouped by kind (US outlets, international outlets, wire services, the US government, state media), not by any rating of the outlets. State media are outlets a government owns or editorially controls, as Wikipedia’s article on each describes it. The summary and the descriptions of each telling are written by AI from the coverage; every quote is checked against the source’s own words. A source’s name and each article’s title link to our analysis of it where we have one; “original ↗” opens the publisher’s page.
Coverage we couldn’t read
Bloomberg: only the opening was available (a paywall, or a page we couldn’t read in full). Iran Targets Bahrain, US Deploys Aircraft Carrier
Al Jazeera (state-funded): only the opening was available (a paywall, or a page we couldn’t read in full). Third US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle East amid tensions with Iran
Al-Monitor: only the opening was available (a paywall, or a page we couldn’t read in full). Third US aircraft carrier arrives in Middle Eastern waters amid Iran standoff
France 24: only the opening was available (a paywall, or a page we couldn’t read in full). Third US aircraft carrier arrives in the Middle East as Iran targets Bahrain
These are linked but not part of the summary or the tellings above.