A second read on the news
Paste any article. See how it’s written and whether its claims hold up.
Or paste the article’s text
2 free analyses a day, no account needed.
No article handy? See one story read from each side: HuffPost · New York Post
What you get back
A TL;DR first, then whether the claims hold up, how it’s written and who gets to speak, with the rhetorical techniques marked in the article itself.
TL;DR
- The piece calls Russia’s war a defense against Western aggression and blames open borders for crime.
- It cites 2.4 million border encounters in fiscal 2023 and over 10,000 civilian deaths in Ukraine.
- A senator it quotes says crime has doubled; it also accuses Republicans of a war on democracy.
Do the claims hold up?
Claims2 checked, both supported; 1 reported claim too vague to check
“Customs and Border Protection recorded more than 2.4 million encounters at the southern border in fiscal year 2023”
Supported by cbp.gov“The United Nations documented over 10,000 civilian deaths in Ukraine since the conflict began in February 2022.”
Supported by ohchr.org“…more than 10,000 civilians killed since Russia's full-scale armed attack…” — ohchr.org ↗
“Crime in our cities has doubled”Said by the senator
Reported claim, not checked Claims the article reports others making are checked as the speaker’s own assertion. This one names no place or period, so there is nothing to check it against.A verdict describes what the named sources say, quoted word for word; it is not a judgement of truth.
How is it written?
Wording3 of 6 paragraphs use rhetorical techniques, all in the writer’s own words
1 more quotes charged language from someone in the story: not counted
HeadlinePROGoes further than the article
“Border chaos fuels crime surge in American cities”Article
“…more than 2.4 million encounters at the southern border in fiscal year 2023…”Nothing in the article measures crime.
A technique isn’t a falsehood: accurate writing uses them too. About wording, sourcing and context, not whether it’s true or which side is right.
Who gets to speak?
Who’s quotedOne-sided: 12 attributed statements
No civilian eyewitness or independent academic is quoted.
What’s missing?
What the article leaves out
- 2014: Russia annexed Crimea and backed separatists in the Donbas, eight years before the full-scale invasion.
- The “denazification” claim: Ukraine’s president is Jewish, and the far right won about 2% in its 2019 election.
The article
underlined: technique founddashed edge: in a quote, not countedtap a technique for why
Russia's special military operation to denazify Ukraine continues as heroic soldiers defend the motherland from Western aggression.
↓Loaded Language · “denazify Ukraine”Why ›
Borrows a word for a historic evil to describe an invasion, so the reader takes the verdict before the facts.Glittering Generalities · “heroic soldiers defend the motherland”Why ›
Praise words stand in for what the soldiers are doing.The United Nations documented over 10,000 civilian deaths in Ukraine since the conflict began in February 2022.
The radical left's open-border agenda is flooding our communities with crime and destroying everything hardworking Americans have built.
↓Appeal to Fear · “flooding our communities with crime”
A threat to the reader’s home, with no figure behind it.Customs and Border Protection recorded more than 2.4 million encounters at the southern border in fiscal year 2023, according to official figures.
“Crime in our cities has doubled because of these animals,” the senator told supporters at a rally on Tuesday.
↓Name Calling · “these animals”Why ›
The article quotes it rather than saying it, so it isn’t counted, but the choice to quote it is worth noticing.Republicans are waging an all-out war on democracy itself, dismantling the very institutions that protect our most fundamental rights.
↑Loaded Language · “waging an all-out war on democracy itself”Why ›
A war metaphor turns a political fight into an attack the reader must resist.“I wanted anyone to be able to see the choices behind the story they’re reading: which claims hold up, which words are doing the persuading, who got quoted and who didn’t, and how the same event reads at a different outlet. Every outlet and every politician is checked by the same rules.”
See what the article doesn’t tell you
Semblen Pro checks an article's factual claims against named sources, and its Deep analysis shows where the headline goes further than the story and who got to speak. It shows how other outlets covered the same story, and each morning a daily digest brings the new stories from outlets you follow, with the techniques marked.
Start 7 days free →Try Pro free for 7 days, no card. Claim checks with their sources, and an email when the stories you follow change. From $5 a month billed yearly. See everything in Pro
20 rhetorical techniques, automatically identified
Rhetorical techniques rarely announce themselves. These are the ones Semblen marks, and explains. Each one, with real examples and where it comes from →
Appeal to Fear
Making you afraid so you stop weighing the facts.
Appeal to Prejudice
Playing on dislike of a group.
Bandwagon Appeal
"everyone's doing it" in place of a reason.
Black-and-White Fallacy
Only two choices when there are more.
Card Stacking
Only the facts that help one side.
Conspiracy Appeal
Hinting at a hidden plot without evidence.
Euphemistic State Language
Soft words for harsh government action.
Exaggeration/Hyperbole
Blowing something up past what is true.
False Equivalence
Treating unequal things as the same.
False Urgency
Pressure to act before you think.
Flag-Waving
Wrapping a position in patriotism.
Glittering Generalities
Feel-good words with no concrete meaning.
Loaded Language
Words picked for the feeling, not the facts.
Name Calling
A label in place of an argument.
Plain Folks Appeal
"i'm just like you" in place of a record.
Repetition
Saying it again until it sticks.
Scapegoating
Blaming one group for a complex problem.
Slogans
A catchy phrase in place of an argument.
Sovereignty Rhetoric
Casting a dispute as a threat to national independence.
Transfer
Borrowing a symbol's feeling for an unrelated claim.