Transfer

Transfer: borrowing a symbol's feeling for an unrelated claim.

How to spot it

Borrowing the feeling attached to a symbol, like the flag, faith, the founders or the troops, and attaching it to a claim that has nothing to do with them. "The founders would be ashamed of this bill" asks you to transfer your respect for the founders to the speaker's view.

What doesn't count

Mentioning a symbol isn't transfer when it's the actual subject: a Veterans Day statement about veterans, a bill about the flag. The technique is the borrowed feeling, not the reference.

Real examples

Each was flagged by Semblen's model, then chosen to stay on this page, so the examples don't change from day to day. A quote in a news article may be the outlet reporting what someone else said, and an ad may be quoting its opponent. Follow each link to check it in context.

In the news

“hunting terrorists and bringing Osama bin Laden to justice”
Is this an example of transfer?
Quoted in The Guardian (US), 2026-08-30
“They stood up to the Soviet Union”
Is this an example of transfer?
Quoted in Straight Arrow News, 2026-09-16
“Hitler was right”
Is this an example of transfer?
Quoted in Washington Free Beacon, 2026-10-08
“compared Ukraine's resistance to Russia to the UK's fight with Nazi Germany”
Is this an example of transfer?
Quoted in BBC News, 2026-08-25
“gracious protectress of the United States”
Is this an example of transfer?
Quoted in Breitbart, 2026-09-25
“an unwavering belief in God”
Is this an example of transfer?
Quoted in The Hill, 2026-08-12

In 2026 campaign ads

“George Washington warned us about the dangers of political parties.”
Is this an example of transfer?
In an ad by Bridgford for Iowa, Iowa House District 1, 2026-10-26
“actually disrespects Jesus”
Is this an example of transfer?
In an ad by James Talarico for Senate, Texas Senate, 2026-09-19

In government statements

“God looked down on his planned paradise and said, "I need a caretaker." So, God gave us Trump”
Is this an example of transfer?
“the speech that ronald reagan gave at the berlin wall”
Is this an example of transfer?
“His steadfast Christian faith gave him the conviction to sail into the unknown”
Is this an example of transfer?
The White House, 2026-10-10
“Thanks to the men and women of America's Armed Forces”
Is this an example of transfer?
The White House on X, 2026-10-09
“during the sacred ceremony honoring the victims of 9/11 at ground zero”
Is this an example of transfer?
Speaker Mike Johnson, 2026-09-24
“our destiny is written by God”
Is this an example of transfer?

Related techniques

Something wrong or unclear on this page?

Tell us. A person reads every note. Use Yes / No under any example if it isn't really transfer: two readers saying no takes it off the page.

Check something yourself

Paste an article, a speech or a video link into the analyzer and Semblen marks the words that use transfer or any other technique, and says why. It flags rhetorical techniques, not political tilt.

Try Pro free for 7 days, no card. Claim checks with their sources, and an email when the stories you follow change.