Argument for
By Dr. Jeffrey Morgan, MD (Ret.), Retired Oncologist and Physician and Retired Instructor of Medicine, Coalition For a Healthy Massachusetts
no rhetorical technique found
MEDICAL AND MENTAL HEALTH PROFESSIONALS, PARENTS, AND BUSINESS OWNERS URGE YES ON QUESTION 8
Question 8 would keep personal possession of marijuana legal, keep medical marijuana legal, and stop commercial marijuana stores
Since commercial legalization, marijuana is now the most common drug found in fatal car accidents in Massachusetts
85% of marijuana users admit to driving after and over 50% drive within an hour or less
Business owners have increased costs from higher rates of workplace injuries, increased healthcare costs, and higher turnover
For every $1 gained in tax revenue, taxpayers spend $4.50 to mitigate the effects of legalization from societal expenses including increased healthcare, lost productivity, and crime (like DUI's)
Modern concentrates and edibles have been linked to mental health conditions like psychosis, severe anxiety, and schizophrenia, particularly in young adults
As a result of commercial marijuana, ER visits in Massachusetts have drastically increased for teenagers with psychiatric conditions
From sec.state.ma.us, the official voter guide.
Argument against
By Ryan Dominguez, Massachusetts Cannabis Coalition
Appeal to FearLoaded Language
VOTE NO ON QUESTION 8
Question 8 would create serious public health and safety problems by repealing the rules and regulations that currently control the production and sale of marijuana in Massachusetts.
For ten years, Massachusetts has regulated marijuana, ensuring that products are tested for safety, packaged and labelled properly, and sold in licensed businesses to adults 21 and over.
Question 8 would undo that progress, returning marijuana to the illicit market where there are no safeguards in place. Law enforcement would be forced to waste time and resources on marijuana arrests instead of fighting serious crime. Historically, marijuana arrests have disproportionately impacted communities of color. Recriminalizing marijuana would make Massachusetts less safe.
Appeal to Fear · “returning marijuana to the illicit market where there are no safeguards in place”, “would make Massachusetts less safe” — Warns of a return to an unsafeguarded illicit market to create anxiety about the ballot measure.
Loaded Language · “forced to waste time and resources” — Uses charged framing like 'forced to waste' to portray enforcement as pointless.
Question 8 would shut down hundreds of small businesses, kill thousands of jobs, and eliminate billions of dollars in state tax revenue.
We must not go backwards on public health and safety.
Vote NO on Question 8.
From sec.state.ma.us, the official voter guide.