Michael Goodwin: The left puts out another smear campaign against Trump — spreading hate on 9/11 anniversary
⚠️ New York Post Opinion has updated this article since we analyzed it. The findings below describe the version we saw on 2026-09-13 — some quoted phrases may no longer appear in the current article.
The article, with notes
underlined: technique found; pick one to highlight its words tap a technique for why
“smear campaign” … “spreading hate”
↓Loaded Language · “smear campaign”, “spreading hate”Why ›
Emotionally charged words like 'smear campaign' and 'spreading hate' are used to trigger a strong negative reaction rather than convey neutral facts.“The left”
↓Name Calling · “The left”Why ›
The collective label 'the left' is used as a derogatory in-group/out-group identifier to discredit a group rather than address specific arguments.“The left puts out another smear campaign against Trump”
↓Appeal to Prejudice · “The left puts out another smear campaign against Trump”Why ›
Framing 'the left' as a unified hostile out-group exploits partisan identity to provoke an emotional in-group response.“9/11 anniversary”
↓Transfer · “9/11 anniversary”Why ›
Invoking the 9/11 anniversary — a deeply sacred and emotionally resonant date — to delegitimize political opponents by associating their actions with desecrating that memory.“rampant hate and prejudice”
↓Exaggeration/Hyperbole · “rampant hate and prejudice”Why ›
The word 'rampant' is an extreme overstatement implying widespread, unchecked hatred without providing evidence to support the scale of the claim.“facts don't matter when left-wing outfits have a narrative to sell”
↓Card Stacking · “facts don't matter when left-wing outfits have a narrative to sell”Why ›
The sentence asserts as established fact that these organizations disregard facts in favor of narratives, presenting only one side of the characterization while omitting any counterevidence or nuance.“preferred narrative that Muslims are perpetual victims”
↓Scapegoating · “preferred narrative that Muslims are perpetual victims”Why ›
The sentence implies that a publication's alleged bias is rooted in protecting a Muslim victimhood narrative, broadly attributing a sinister editorial motive tied to a religious group.“The only way to explain the media failure to see the connection is that it's intentional”
↓Conspiracy Appeal · “The only way to explain the media failure to see the connection is that it's intentional”Why ›
The sentence implies that media outlets are deliberately hiding or ignoring a connection, suggesting a coordinated hidden agenda rather than offering alternative explanations such as editorial judgment or differing interpretations.“The only way to explain the media failure to see the connection is that it's intentional”
↑Black-and-White Fallacy · “The only way to explain the media failure to see the connection is that it's intentional”Why ›
The phrase 'the only way to explain' eliminates all other possible explanations (oversight, differing editorial priorities, genuine disagreement) and forces a single sinister conclusion.Analyzed 2026-09-13 04:17 UTC. Articles are sometimes updated after publication — if a quote here isn't in the current version, the piece has changed since.
Analyzed automatically with Semblen's fine-tuned model. These are rhetorical techniques, not political tilt — and finding one is not a claim that the article is false. Findings include language the outlet is quoting rather than asserting: we flag techniques wherever they appear, so check each quote against the original. The model has known false positives on strong-but-legitimate language, so treat each finding as a prompt to read closely, not a verdict. How articles are chosen →